Super Chewer vs Bullymake: Which Survives a Power Chewer?

The Bottom Line

Super Chewer and Bullymake are the two serious answers to the same problem: a dog that opens a plush toy in under ten minutes. Both build toys from rubber and nylon rather than fabric, and both back them with a 14-day replacement if your dog destroys one.

• Choose Super Chewer for most dogs. It costs less, rates 4.5 to Bullymake’s 3.5, and it comes from a company that answers its complaints.
• Choose Bullymake if you want more in the box and US manufacturing, and you accept a service record that we cap at 3.5.

Bullymake genuinely gives you more per box. That is not the deciding factor, and the reason is worth reading before you subscribe.

The Service Records Are Not Comparable

Both of these companies sell tough toys to frustrated dog owners. Only one of them reliably answers when something goes wrong.

Bullymake holds a Trustpilot score of 4.4 from about 2,300 reviews, which is genuinely good. Owners consistently report the rubber toys lasting months, which is the whole promise. Its BBB file tells a different story: a grade of D-, with 21 complaints on record and all 21 unanswered.

That combination is unusual and worth understanding. Most customers are happy. The small number who escalate to BBB get no response at all. A company can have both, and Bullymake does.

Super Chewer shares BARK’s corporate profile: 4.7 on Trustpilot from about 9,700 reviews, and a BBB file that is A+ and accredited with 349 complaints, all answered. BARK has far more complaints in absolute terms because it is a far larger company. It responds to them.

On our methodology a BBB grade of D or F caps a box’s overall rating at 3.5 regardless of product quality. Bullymake sits at that ceiling. Super Chewer rates 4.5.

Why we weight this so heavily here specifically: the durability guarantee is a core part of what both companies sell. A 14-day replacement promise is only worth what the company’s willingness to honour it is worth. Buying a guarantee from a business that answers none of its formal complaints is a weaker proposition than the same guarantee from one that answers all of them, even when the second company generates more complaints overall.

What You Get for the Money

Bullymake wins the contents comparison outright, and it is not close.

Full-size treat bags are a real difference. Super Chewer’s treats are portioned for a monthly box; Bullymake’s are the size you would buy at a pet store. If treats are a meaningful part of your spend, Bullymake absorbs more of that cost.

The US manufacturing claim also matters to some buyers, and Bullymake states it plainly while BARK does not make an equivalent claim.

On Actual Durability

Neither company sells an indestructible toy, and you should be sceptical of any review that says otherwise.

The consistent owner reporting on Bullymake is that its rubber and nylon toys last months, while its softer fabric items do not. If you buy Bullymake, weight your customisation toward rubber.

The consistent reporting on Super Chewer is similar: tough toys hold up well against most power chewers, and determined large breeds still get through some of them inside a week. The 14-day replacement exists because BARK expects failures.

If your dog has already destroyed a solid rubber toy from a specialist brand, neither subscription is going to solve that. At that point you are buying individual heavy-duty toys chosen for your specific dog rather than a monthly assortment, and a subscription is the wrong product.

Price, Properly

Super Chewer’s $29 is the 12-month rate. Month to month runs closer to $40, which is the number to compare against Bullymake’s $39 if you do not want to commit for a year.

So the real picture:

• Committing to a year: Super Chewer at $29 against Bullymake at $39. Super Chewer is $120 a year cheaper.
• Month to month: $45 against $39, so Bullymake is the cheaper of the two, and it also sends more. On contents per dollar without a commitment, Bullymake wins outright.

That is the strongest case for Bullymake: if you refuse to commit for twelve months, you get more for less money. You are trading the service record for the contents, and month to month that trade is a real one rather than a marginal one.

Sizing and Customisation

Both let you tune the box, and they do it on different axes, which matters more than it sounds.

Super Chewer sizes by dog weight across small, medium, and large, and lets you exclude proteins for allergies. The toys within a size are broadly the same for everyone that month, because the box is built around a monthly theme.

Bullymake sizes by weight and also asks about chew strength and toy preference, so you can steer toward rubber and away from nylon or fabric. Given that owner reports consistently say its rubber items outlast its softer ones, that control is the difference between a box that works and one that does not. It also offers grain-free and allergy-friendly treat swaps.

If your dog has a clear material preference, Bullymake lets you act on it. If you want variety and surprise, Super Chewer’s themed approach delivers that better.

Common Questions

Do either of these work for a dog that destroys everything?

Partly. Both will last longer than a plush toy, and neither is indestructible. Use the 14-day guarantee, steer toward rubber, and accept that the most destructive dogs need individually chosen heavy-duty toys rather than a subscription.

Which has better treats?

Bullymake, on volume. Three full-size bags is more than Super Chewer’s two portioned treats, and full-size bags displace a pet-store purchase. Neither should be a meaningful part of a diet.

Can I pause or skip?

Both allow skipping from your account. Do it before the billing date rather than after, since billing after an intended cancellation is the single most common complaint against each company.

Is the annual plan worth it?

For Super Chewer, yes, if you are confident you will keep it. It drops the price from $45 to $29, a 36% saving. For Bullymake, weigh the twelve-month commitment against a company that has not answered any of its BBB complaints.

Who Should Choose Super Chewer?

Choose Super Chewer if you:

• Want the lower price, especially on an annual plan
• Want a company with a documented, working complaints process
• Value BARK’s monthly themes and design
• Might want to switch to BarkBox Classic later if your dog’s chewing eases
• Would rather have fewer, well-supported items than more items

Who Should Choose Bullymake?

Choose Bullymake if you:

• Want the extra toy and three full-size treat bags
• Specifically want toys manufactured in the USA
• Are subscribing month to month, where the prices are effectively equal
• Have a dog that does best on rubber rather than nylon or fabric
• Accept that if a dispute escalates, the BBB record suggests you may not get a reply

Final Recommendation

Super Chewer, for most power chewers. Cheaper on an annual plan, better rated, and backed by a company that answers complaints. When you are buying a durability guarantee, the company’s willingness to honour it is part of the product.

Bullymake, if contents matter more than recourse. Three full-size treat bags and up to three toys is more than Super Chewer sends, the toys are well regarded by owners, and at month-to-month pricing it is the better value on paper. Its 4.4 Trustpilot score says most customers never need support.

Either way: customise toward rubber, use the 14-day guarantee promptly rather than waiting, and set a reminder before your renewal. Billing after an intended cancellation is the most common complaint against both companies.