BarkBox vs Super Chewer: Which Dog Subscription Box Is Right for Your Pup?

The Bottom Line

Both BarkBox and Super Chewer come from the same company (Bark & Co.), but they serve different types of dogs:

• Choose BarkBox Classic if your dog is a gentle to moderate chewer who enjoys variety in toys and treats
• Choose Super Chewer if your dog destroys standard toys within minutes and needs extra-durable playthings

The $6/month price difference is justified if your dog is an aggressive chewer, as Super Chewer’s durable toys last significantly longer and come with a replacement guarantee.

What’s the Main Difference?

The core difference is toy durability:

BarkBox Classic

• Standard plush and rope toys
• Great for dogs who play gently
• More variety in toy types and styles
• Fun themed boxes each month

Super Chewer

• Rubber, nylon, and ballistic nylon construction
• Built for dogs with powerful jaws
• 14-day durability guarantee (they’ll replace destroyed toys)
• Fewer toy styles, but much tougher

Detailed Comparison

Toy Quality & Durability

BarkBox Classic: Toys are adorable, well-designed, and themed. However, they’re made with standard materials that aggressive chewers can destroy quickly. If your dog treats toys gently and you value cute, creative designs, BarkBox excels here.

Super Chewer Winner: If your dog can demolish a plush toy in under 10 minutes, Super Chewer is the clear choice. The toys are built like tanks, with reinforced seams, tough rubber, and durable materials. Plus, the 14-day replacement guarantee means if your dog does destroy a toy, Bark will send a replacement.

Treat Quality

BarkBox Classic: All-natural treats and chews. Good quality, but not as substantial as Super Chewer’s offerings.

Super Chewer Winner: Premium meat-based treats and long-lasting chews. These are meatier, heartier, and more expensive treats that power chewers will love.

Value for Money

This depends entirely on your dog:

• For gentle chewers: BarkBox Classic offers better value at $29/month with more variety
• For power chewers: Super Chewer is worth the extra $6/month because:
  • Toys last 10x longer
  • Replacement guarantee saves money
  • Premium treats are higher quality

If you’re currently buying a new toy every week because your dog destroys them ($10-15 each), Super Chewer actually saves money.

Customization Options

Both boxes offer:

• Monthly, 6-month, or 12-month plans (save with longer commitments)
• Dog size selection (small, medium, large)
• Allergy-friendly treat options
• Ability to skip a month
• Themed holiday boxes

No significant difference in customization between the two.

Who Should Choose BarkBox Classic?

Choose BarkBox if your dog:

• Plays gently with toys
• Doesn’t destroy plush toys immediately
• Enjoys variety in toy types (plush, rope, crinkle, etc.)
• Is motivated more by play than aggressive chewing
• Is a puppy learning to play nicely

Ideal for: Gentle chewers, senior dogs, small breeds, dogs who collect toys rather than destroy them

Who Should Choose Super Chewer?

Choose Super Chewer if your dog:

• Destroys standard toys in minutes
• Has powerful jaws (pit bulls, shepherds, mastiffs, etc.)
• Prefers durable rubber toys over plush
• Needs long-lasting chews to stay occupied
• Has cost you a fortune in destroyed toys

Ideal for: Power chewers, working breeds, high-energy dogs, aggressive chewers, large breeds with strong jaws

Can You Switch Between Them?

Yes! Bark makes it easy to switch between BarkBox Classic and Super Chewer month-to-month based on your needs. This is perfect if:

• You want to try both to see which your dog prefers
• Your dog’s chewing habits change over time
• You want variety (some months Classic, some months Super Chewer)

Money-Saving Tips

1. Annual plans save 20%+: Both boxes offer significant discounts on 12-month subscriptions
2. First box deals: Look for promo codes for discounted first boxes (often 50% off)
3. Add extra toys: You can add extra toys à la carte for less than retail
4. Replacement guarantee: Super Chewer’s 14-day guarantee effectively makes it cheaper if your dog is destructive

Common Questions

Can I get both subscriptions?

Yes, you can subscribe to both if you have multiple dogs with different chewing styles, or if you want maximum variety.

What if my dog is somewhere in between?

Try BarkBox Classic first since it’s cheaper. If toys are destroyed immediately, switch to Super Chewer. Bark makes switching easy.

Are treats included in both?

Yes, both boxes include 2 bags of treats per month, though Super Chewer’s are meatier and more substantial.

Can I return a box if my dog doesn’t like it?

Bark has a satisfaction guarantee. Contact customer service if there’s an issue.

Final Recommendation

For most dogs: Start with BarkBox Classic. It’s more affordable and you can always upgrade to Super Chewer if needed.

For known power chewers: Go straight to Super Chewer. The durability guarantee alone makes it worth the extra cost if your dog destroys standard toys.

Best of both worlds: Subscribe to Super Chewer for toys, and supplement with BarkBox-style treats from other sources if you want more variety.

Both are excellent subscription boxes with 4.3+ ratings on Trustpilot. You really can’t go wrong with either, it just depends on your dog’s chewing style.