Bullymake

Bullymake delivers 2-3 extremely tough rubber or nylon toys plus 3 full-size bags of treats monthly, specifically designed for aggressive chewers. Founded in 2014 by bull terrier owners, every toy is built to withstand powerful jaws with a 14-day satisfaction guarantee and free replacements if your dog destroys anything.

Bullymake has been the go-to subscription for power chewer owners since 2014, when founders created it specifically for their bull terrier who destroyed every toy within hours. Unlike general pet subscriptions that include flimsy toys alongside treats, Bullymake focuses exclusively on durability, every toy is engineered to withstand the most aggressive jaws.

The company has built a loyal following among owners of pit bulls, bulldogs, German shepherds, and other breeds known for demolishing standard pet store toys. Their 14-day guarantee isn’t marketing fluff, they actually send free replacements when dogs manage to destroy toys, which builds genuine trust with skeptical owners who’ve spent hundreds on toys that lasted minutes.

Pricing Plans

Plan	Price	Per Box	Commitment
Monthly	$45/month	$45.00	Month-to-month
3-Month	$117 prepaid	$39.00	3 months
6-Month	$222 prepaid	$37.00	6 months
12-Month	$408 prepaid	$34.00	12 months

All plans include free shipping. First box ships within 24-48 hours of ordering.

What’s Included

Each monthly Bullymake box contains:

2-3 Heavy-Duty Toys: Made from ultra-tough rubber or nylon materials designed to withstand powerful jaws. Toys are sized based on your dog’s weight and chewing intensity.

3 Full-Size Treat Bags: Premium treats with options for grain-free, chicken-free, beef-free, and other allergy accommodations. All treats are made in USA or Canada.

14-Day Durability Guarantee: If your dog destroys any toy within 14 days, contact Bullymake for a free replacement. This applies to the toy’s structure, normal wear like scratches doesn’t qualify.

Customization Options:

• Toy-only boxes available for dogs with severe allergies
• Nylon vs. rubber preferences
• Size appropriate for your dog’s weight class

How It Works

1. Complete the Detailed Quiz: Begin by answering comprehensive questions about your dog’s profile including breed, weight, age, chewing intensity level, and any dietary restrictions. The quiz specifically asks about chewing style, whether your dog gnaws methodically, shakes toys violently, or tears at seams, to match appropriate toy materials. This information ensures each box is tailored to your dog’s specific destructive tendencies.

2. Select Your Subscription Plan: Choose from 3, 6, or 12-month subscription commitments. While Bullymake doesn’t offer a true month-to-month option, the 3-month minimum allows you to test the service without excessive commitment. Longer plans provide substantial savings, the 12-month plan costs $34/box compared to $45 for monthly billing, representing over 24% savings.

3. Specify Customization Preferences: Indicate if you want a toy-only box for dogs with severe food allergies, or the standard toys-and-treats combination. Select treat restrictions including chicken-free, beef-free, turkey-free, or grain-free options. Choose between rubber and nylon toy preferences based on your dog’s chewing style and past success with different materials.

4. Receive Your First Box: Initial shipment processes within 24-48 hours of subscription confirmation. Boxes arrive via standard shipping (typically 3-7 business days depending on location). Each subsequent box ships automatically around the 15th of the month, arriving before month-end to ensure continuous toy supply.

5. Introduce Toys to Your Power Chewer: Present the new toys to your dog and observe their interaction. Note how they approach each item, some dogs prefer rubber toys for gnawing while others target nylon for aggressive biting. This observation helps refine future preferences if you contact customer service with feedback.

6. Test the 14-Day Durability Guarantee: If your dog manages to destroy any toy within 14 days of receipt, photograph the damaged item and contact Bullymake customer service via email or their website portal. The guarantee covers structural destruction, cracking, ripping, or breaking into pieces, not normal surface wear like scratches or tooth marks.

7. Receive Free Replacement Toys: Upon verification of destruction within the guarantee period, Bullymake ships replacement toys at no additional charge. This no-questions-asked policy has built tremendous loyalty among power chewer owners who’ve experienced broken promises from other brands. Some customers report receiving multiple replacements before finding toys their dogs couldn’t destroy.

8. Provide Ongoing Feedback: Rate toys through follow-up emails or your account dashboard. Bullymake uses this feedback to improve their product lineup and may adjust your future boxes based on reported preferences. Dogs who consistently destroy certain toy types may receive alternative materials in subsequent shipments.

Who It’s For

Perfect For:

• Owners of pit bulls, bulldogs, German shepherds, and other power breeds
• Dogs who destroy regular toys within minutes or hours
• Pet parents frustrated with wasting money on flimsy toys
• Those who want USA-made, non-toxic toy options
• Owners seeking allergy-friendly treat alternatives

Consider Alternatives If:

• Your dog is a moderate chewer (BarkBox offers more variety at lower cost)
• You want more items per box (Bullymake focuses on quality over quantity)
• Month-to-month flexibility is important (3-month minimum commitment)
• Budget is tight (premium pricing reflects durability focus)

Durability Testing

Bullymake’s quality control process includes:

• Material testing with actual aggressive chewing dogs
• Non-toxic material certification
• USA manufacturing oversight
• Continuous improvement based on customer feedback

The company actively collects data on which toys last longest with different breeds and adjusts their product lineup accordingly. This iterative approach has refined their offerings to genuinely withstand power chewing over the years.