The Sill Plant of the Month Club

The Sill's Plant of the Month Club delivers a new houseplant nestled in a stylish ceramic planter each month. Choose between Easy-Care, Pet-Friendly, or Orchid subscriptions. Each 3 or 6-month commitment includes plants, planters, and free shipping with no duplicates during your subscription.

The Sill has built a devoted following as the modern plant company that makes it easy to bring greenery into everyday life. Founded in 2012 by Eliza Blank in New York City, the company grew from a small Kickstarter campaign to a brand with multiple physical stores, a thriving online presence, and the Plant of the Month Club subscription that brings their design-forward approach to plant care directly to subscribers’ doors.

What sets The Sill apart from basic plant deliveries is the complete package: each monthly delivery includes not just a plant but a stylish ceramic planter that fits modern home decor. The company positions itself as more than a plant retailer - it’s a plant education company, providing care guides and support to help subscribers develop confidence as plant parents.

Trust Note: The Sill has a 4.1/5 Trustpilot rating from 225 reviews, though Trustpilot flagged potential review solicitation concerns. Their BBB rating is A (not A+) with 9 complaints, primarily around customer service response times. Reviews are mixed - many praise the aesthetic and education, while others report plants arriving damaged or dying quickly. The 30-Day guarantee exists but may require persistence.

Pricing Plans

The Sill offers straightforward subscription pricing:

Subscription	Duration	Monthly Cost	Total
Easy-Care	3 months	$55/month	$165
Easy-Care	6 months	$55/month	$330
Pet-Friendly	3 months	~$57-58/month	~$174
Pet-Friendly	6 months	~$57-58/month	~$348
Orchid	3 months	$55/month	$165
Orchid	6 months	$55/month	$330

All prices include plant, ceramic planter, and shipping.

Note: Pet-friendly plants cost $2-3 more per month because non-toxic plant varieties are harder to source.

What’s Included

Each monthly delivery contains:

• One Houseplant: Variety changes monthly, no duplicates during subscription
• Ceramic Planter: 5-inch diameter in white or grey (your choice)
• Plant in Grow Pot: 4-inch diameter nested inside the ceramic planter
• Care Instructions: Guidance for your specific plant variety
• Free Shipping: Included in subscription cost

Subscription Tracks:

• Easy-Care: Low-maintenance plants for beginners (pothos, snake plants, ZZ plants, etc.)
• Pet-Friendly: Non-toxic varieties safe for cats and dogs
• Orchid: Monthly orchid delivery for flowering plant lovers

How It Works

Getting started with The Sill Plant of the Month Club involves selecting the subscription track that matches your needs: Easy-Care for low-maintenance varieties, Pet-Friendly for non-toxic plants safe around cats and dogs, or Orchid for those who love flowering plants. You then choose your commitment duration of either 3 or 6 months, along with your preferred ceramic planter color in white or grey.

Once subscribed, a new plant arrives every 30 days, each nestled in a 4-inch grow pot inside your chosen 5-inch ceramic planter. Care guides accompany each delivery to help you keep your growing collection healthy. Unlike many subscriptions, The Sill does not auto-renew, so your subscription simply ends after your 3 or 6 deliveries without surprise charges, and you can actively re-subscribe if you wish to continue.

Plant Varieties

The Sill’s subscription includes different plant types depending on which track you select. The Easy-Care track features low-maintenance varieties perfect for beginners, including various pothos cultivars known for their trailing vines, snake plants that tolerate neglect, ZZ plants that thrive in low light, philodendrons with their classic heart-shaped leaves, and dracaenas that add height to any space.

The Pet-Friendly track focuses on non-toxic varieties safe for households with cats and dogs. Expect to receive spider plants with their arching leaves, calatheas featuring striking patterned foliage, compact peperomias in various shapes and textures, parlor palms that add tropical flair, and air plants that require no soil.

The Orchid track delivers phalaenopsis orchids each month in various colors and varieties, appealing to those who appreciate flowering plants and the elegance that orchids bring to home decor.

Who It’s For

The Sill Plant of the Month Club appeals to design-conscious plant lovers who value aesthetics and appreciate having matching planters for their collection. Urban apartment dwellers find value in building a plant collection through convenient delivery without trips to nurseries. Pet owners benefit specifically from the Pet-Friendly track that ensures all plant selections are safe for cats and dogs. Gift givers appreciate the impressive monthly presentation that makes the subscription a memorable ongoing present. Beginners seeking guidance find The Sill’s educational approach helpful as they develop confidence as plant parents.

However, the subscription may not suit everyone’s needs. Budget-conscious shoppers should note that $55 per month represents premium pricing compared to local nursery alternatives. Experienced plant parents who prefer choosing specific varieties may find the curated approach limiting. Those without reliable climate control should consider that some plants may struggle during delivery transit, particularly in extreme weather. The minimum 3-month commitment may deter those who prefer more flexibility, and international customers should be aware that The Sill only ships within the US.

Comparison with Alternatives

Feature	The Sill	Horti	Local Nursery
Price	$55/month	$25-36/month	Varies
Planter Included	Ceramic (choice of color)	Terracotta (optional)	Usually no
Pet-Friendly Option	Yes (+$2-3)	Yes (same price)	Research required
Commitment	3-6 months	Flexible	None
Shipping	Free	Additional	N/A
Plant Quality	Generally good	Generally good	See before buying
Selection Control	None (curated)	Limited (3 tracks)	Full control

The Sill is best for those who value the complete package - plant, stylish planter, education, and brand experience. For pure plant value, local shopping or Horti may stretch your budget further.

The Premium Plant Subscription Decision

At $55/month, The Sill represents a significant investment compared to alternatives. Understanding what you’re paying for helps determine if the premium is worthwhile for your situation.

The Planter Value: Each delivery includes a ceramic planter worth $15-25 retail. Over a 6-month subscription, that’s $90-150 in planters alone. If you appreciate matching, design-forward containers, this adds genuine value. If you’d rather choose your own pots or already have planters, you’re paying for something you don’t need.

The Brand Experience: The Sill has built a lifestyle brand, not just a plant retailer. The educational content, care guides, and community aspects create an experience beyond the physical products. For those who value brand engagement and want to feel part of the modern plant parent movement, this intangible value matters.

Physical Store Access: With locations in NYC, LA, and San Francisco, The Sill offers something online-only competitors can’t: the ability to walk in, see plants in person, get hands-on advice, and return to the store if issues arise. For residents in these cities, this hybrid support justifies premium pricing.

When Premium Makes Sense: The Sill subscription works best for urban dwellers who value design aesthetics, appreciate the ceramic planter included with each delivery, want a recognized brand experience, and live near a physical store for support. The combination of convenience, curation, and style justifies the cost for those who would otherwise spend similar amounts assembling the same package piecemeal.

When Budget Options Win: If you prioritize value over aesthetics, would choose your own planters anyway, or live far from physical stores, Horti offers comparable plants at half the price. Local nursery shopping provides even better value with the added benefit of choosing exactly what you want.