ButcherBox vs Wild Alaskan Company: Meat & Seafood Delivery Comparison
Compare ButcherBox and Wild Alaskan Company for premium protein delivery. We analyze quality, sourcing, value, and which is best for your kitchen.
ButcherBox
Premium grass-fed beef, free-range chicken, and heritage pork delivered monthly with customizable cuts and quantities.
Wild Alaskan Company
Premium wild-caught Alaskan seafood delivered monthly, sourced directly from sustainable fisheries by third-generation fishermen.
Detailed Comparison
| Comparison Factor | ButcherBox | Wild Alaskan Company |
|---|---|---|
| Price Range | $146-306/month | $99-336/month |
| Protein Focus | ✓ Beef, chicken, pork, seafood | Wild-caught seafood only |
| Sourcing | Grass-fed, free-range, humanely raised | Wild-caught, sustainable Alaska |
| Variety | ✓ High (multiple proteins) | Moderate (fish & shellfish) |
| Sustainability | Good (humane farms) | ✓ Excellent (Marine Stewardship Council) |
| Customization | Choose your cuts | Choose your species |
The Bottom Line
These services serve different protein needs:
- Choose ButcherBox if you want variety across beef, chicken, pork, and seafood with ethically sourced meat
- Choose Wild Alaskan Company if you prioritize wild-caught, sustainable seafood and love fish
Quick Comparison
| Feature | ButcherBox | Wild Alaskan Company |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Multiple proteins | Seafood only |
| Price Range | $146-306/month | $99-336/month |
| Box Size | 8.5-14+ lbs | 10-24+ lbs |
| Frequency | Monthly | Monthly |
| Sourcing | Grass-fed, free-range | Wild-caught Alaska |
| Sustainability | Humane farms | MSC certified |
What’s In Each Box?
ButcherBox
Each box includes a mix of:
- 100% grass-fed beef (ribeyes, ground beef, steaks)
- Free-range organic chicken
- Heritage-breed pork
- Wild-caught seafood
- 8.5-14+ pounds depending on plan
Wild Alaskan Company
Each box features:
- Wild-caught salmon (sockeye, king, coho)
- Halibut, cod, rockfish
- Scallops, shrimp
- 10-24+ pounds depending on plan
- All from sustainable Alaskan fisheries
Quality & Sourcing
ButcherBox Quality
- 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef
- Free-range organic chicken
- Heritage-breed, pasture-raised pork
- Never any antibiotics or hormones
- Humanely raised on partner farms
Wild Alaskan Company Quality
- Wild-caught (never farmed)
- Sourced from Alaskan waters
- Flash-frozen at peak freshness
- Marine Stewardship Council certified
- Sustainable fishing practices
Both deliver exceptional quality from ethical, sustainable sources.
Pricing Breakdown
ButcherBox Plans
| Plan | Price | Approx. Per Lb |
|---|---|---|
| Custom Classic (8.5-11 lbs) | $146/mo | ~$15/lb |
| Custom Big (17-21 lbs) | $269/mo | ~$14/lb |
| Custom Huge (20-26 lbs) | $306/mo | ~$13/lb |
Wild Alaskan Company Plans
| Plan | Price | Approx. Per Lb |
|---|---|---|
| Wild (10 lbs) | $99/mo | ~$10/lb |
| Wild x2 (16 lbs) | $169/mo | ~$10.50/lb |
| Wild x4 (24 lbs) | $336/mo | ~$14/lb |
Who Should Choose ButcherBox?
Choose ButcherBox if you:
- Want variety across different proteins
- Eat beef, chicken, and pork regularly
- Care about grass-fed and humane sourcing
- Want one source for all your protein needs
- Like customizing cuts each month
Who Should Choose Wild Alaskan Company?
Choose Wild Alaskan Company if you:
- Love seafood and want to eat more fish
- Prioritize wild-caught over farmed
- Care deeply about sustainable fishing
- Want the highest-quality seafood available
- Live far from quality fish markets
Can You Get Both?
Many families subscribe to both:
- ButcherBox for meat proteins (beef, chicken, pork)
- Wild Alaskan Company for premium seafood
This ensures a fully stocked freezer with ethically sourced proteins for every meal.
Final Recommendation
For protein variety: ButcherBox is the complete solution for households that eat beef, chicken, pork, and some seafood.
For seafood lovers: Wild Alaskan Company delivers unmatched quality wild-caught fish that’s hard to find at grocery stores.
Both services offer free shipping, quality guarantees, and flexible delivery schedules.
Research Sources
- • ButcherBox Official Website (Accessed 1/29/2026)
- • Wild Alaskan Company Official Website (Accessed 1/29/2026)
Related Comparisons
Also Consider in Food & Snacks
Sips by
Personalized tea subscription with 4 craft teas monthly matched to your taste profile, 45+ cups per box.
Sun Basket
Organic meal kits with chef-crafted recipes supporting 10+ dietary plans including paleo, keto, and Mediterranean.
CookUnity
Chef-crafted meals delivered fresh, featuring diverse cuisines from top culinary talent.