Book of the Month vs OwlCrate: Book Box Comparison

The Bottom Line

These are very different book subscription experiences:

• Choose Book of the Month if you want affordable hardcovers with the freedom to choose your book each month
• Choose OwlCrate if you love YA fantasy/romance and want a full unboxing experience with exclusive items

Quick Comparison

What You Get

Book of the Month

• 1 new hardcover book (your choice of 5)
• Exclusive early-release titles
• Option to add extra books for $14.99
• Skip any month for free
• No commitment required

OwlCrate

• 1 new YA hardcover (often signed/exclusive edition)
• 3-5 bookish items themed to the book
• Items like candles, bookmarks, art prints, pins
• Exclusive cover art or special editions
• Full unboxing experience

Book Selection Process

Book of the Month

• Expert judges select 5 books monthly
• YOU choose which book you want
• Mix of literary fiction, thrillers, romance, nonfiction
• Add-ons available at member prices
• See all options before deciding

OwlCrate

• Curators select ONE YA title
• Surprise reveal each month
• Focus on fantasy, romance, and adventure
• Themes announced in advance
• Trust the curation

Winner: Book of the Month for choice; OwlCrate for curated surprises.

Value Analysis

Book of the Month

• $17.99 for new hardcover (retail $25-30)
• Immediate value: ~$10 savings per book
• Add-on books: $14.99 (more savings)
• No fluff, just books

OwlCrate

• $34.99 for book + items
• Retail value: $70-100+
• Exclusive editions worth more to collectors
• Items add experience value

For pure readers: Book of the Month wins on price. For collectors: OwlCrate’s exclusives and items justify the price.

Who Should Choose Book of the Month?

Choose BOTM if you:

• Just want good books at great prices
• Read adult fiction and nonfiction
• Want to choose your own books
• Don’t need extra items
• Appreciate flexibility to skip months

Who Should Choose OwlCrate?

Choose OwlCrate if you:

• Love YA fantasy and romance
• Enjoy the unboxing experience
• Collect bookish merchandise
• Want signed or exclusive editions
• Love themed surprises

Can You Subscribe to Both?

Absolutely! Many avid readers do:

• BOTM for adult reading picks
• OwlCrate for YA indulgence and collectibles

The total ($52.98/month) is still less than buying 2 hardcovers + merchandise at retail.

Final Recommendation

For budget-conscious readers: Book of the Month delivers excellent value with quality picks and total flexibility.

For YA book lovers: OwlCrate creates a magical experience beyond just reading, it’s a celebration of book culture.

Both services offer easy cancellation, so try whichever matches your reading style.