Loot Crate

Loot Crate launched in 2012 as one of the first subscription boxes dedicated to geek culture. Founded by Chris Davis and Matthew Arevalo, it quickly became the go-to source for exclusive collectibles that fans couldn’t find anywhere else.

Company Mission

Loot Crate celebrates fandom by delivering exclusive merchandise from the franchises fans love most. Their mission is to create connection and community among collectors through shared enthusiasm for gaming, anime, and pop culture.

Products & Services (2026)

Active Subscriptions:

• Loot Crate: Original pop culture box with diverse themes ($29.99/month + $6 shipping)
• Wizarding World: Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts exclusives ($39.99 bi-monthly)

Inactive/Discontinued:

• Loot Fright: Horror-themed collectibles (currently sold out)
• Loot Anime: Anime and manga collectibles (discontinued December 2023)
• Loot Gaming: Video game merchandise (inactive since June 2025)

What Sets Them Apart

Loot Crate partners directly with major franchises to create items you won’t find in stores. From officially licensed apparel to limited-edition figures, each crate delivers collector-focused items designed specifically for the subscription. Their themed approach means every box tells a story.

Company Challenges

Loot Crate filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in August 2019 after rapid expansion led to operational difficulties. The company emerged from bankruptcy later that year but has continued to face fulfillment challenges, shipping delays, and customer service issues.

Current Status:

• 1.6 Trustpilot rating (out of 5) based on 4,200+ reviews
• F rating from Better Business Bureau
• Ongoing complaints about shipping delays and poor customer service
• Reduced subscription offerings (from 4+ active subscriptions to 2)

Despite these challenges, Loot Crate continues to operate and fulfill subscriptions. However, prospective subscribers should be aware of the company’s history and check recent reviews before subscribing. Starting with shorter subscription terms rather than prepaid annual plans is recommended.